National Historical RegisterIndependent guide · not a government site

National Register listings in Yates County, New York

66 listings 4 districts 64 with nomination summaries Updated October 2026
Open in OpenStreetMap

Most notable listings

Barden Cobblestone Farmhouse Benton · Building · listed 1992 Bates Cobblestone Farmhouse Middlesex · Building · listed 1992 Crooked Lake Outlet Historic District Penn Yan · District · listed 1996 Dundee Village Historic District Dundee · District · listed 2007 Earl, Jephtha, Cobblestone Farmhouse Benton · Building · listed 1992 Esperanza Jerusalem · Building · listed 1995 First Presbyterian Church Dundee · Building · listed 2004 Garrett Memorial Chapel Bluff Point · Building · listed 2001 Ingersoll, Robert, Birthplace Dresden · Building · listed 1988 Lake View Cemetery Penn Yan · Site · listed 1996

Historic districts (4)

All listings

Places: Jerusalem (15) · Penn Yan (8) · Benton (6) · Middlesex (6) · Starkey (6) · Milo (4) · Dundee (4) · Branchport (4) · Italy (3) · Potter (3) · Dresden (2) · Milo Center (1)

NamePlaceTypeListed
Angus Cobblestone Farmhouse and Barn Complex Benton Building 1992
Bailey, Jonathan, House Milo Building 1994
Barden Cobblestone Farmhouse Benton Building 1992
Bates Cobblestone Farmhouse Middlesex Building 1992
Beddoe-Rose Family Cemetery Jerusalem Site 2014
Bitley, Peter, House Jerusalem Building 1994
Bitley, Thomas, House Jerusalem Building 1994
Botsford, Samuel, House Jerusalem Building 1994
Briggs, John, House Milo Center Building 1994
Carr, John, House Middlesex Building 1994
Crooked Lake Outlet Historic District Penn Yan District 1996
Curtis, Thomas Bennett, House Starkey Building 1994
Dundee Methodist Church Dundee Building 2005
Dundee Village Historic District Dundee District 2007
Earl, Jephtha, Cobblestone Farmhouse Benton Building 1992
Esperanza Jerusalem Building 1995
First Presbyterian Church Dundee Building 2004
Fox, James, House Italy Building 1994
Garrett Memorial Chapel Bluff Point Building 2001
Green, Asahel, Farm Middlesex Building 1994
Hair, Uriah, House Dundee Building 1994
Hampstead Jerusalem Building 1994
Hanford, Uriah, House Jerusalem Building 1994
Hays, George, House Jerusalem Building 1994
Himrod Baptist Church Milo Building 1994
Hobart, James, House Potter Building 1994
Ingersoll, Robert, Birthplace Dresden Building 1988
Italy Valley Methodist Church Italy Building 1994
Lake View Cemetery Penn Yan Site 1996
Larzelere Tavern Branchport Building 1997
McLoud, Smith, House Italy Building 1994
Middlesex Center Methodist Church Middlesex Building 1994
Morrison, Roderick M., House Penn Yan Building 1994
Nichols, William, Cobblestone Farmhouse Benton Building 1992
Noyes, John, House Starkey Building 1994
Overackers Corners Schoolhouse Middlesex Building 1994
Penn Yan Historic District Penn Yan District 1985
Perry, Ezikial, House Jerusalem Building 1994
Potter, Arnold, House Potter Building 1994
Raplee, Miles, House Milo Building 1994
Sampson Theatre Penn Yan Building 2008
Sill Tenant House Jerusalem Building 1994
Spence, Dr. Henry, Cobblestone Farmhouse and Barn Complex Starkey Building 1992
Spicer-Millard House Barrington Building 1994
St. Luke's Episcopal Church Jerusalem Building 1994
Starkey United Methodist Church Starkey Building 1994
Supplee, Daniel, Cobblestone Farmhouse Starkey Building 1992
Swarthout, William, Farm Milo Building 1994
Swortz, William, House Starkey Building 1994
US Post Office-Penn Yan Penn Yan Building 1989
Vine Valley Methodist Church Middlesex Building 1994
Wagener, Abraham, House Jerusalem Building 1994
Wagener, Charles, House Penn Yan Building 1994
Wagener, H. Allen, House Jerusalem Building 1994
Weaver, Myron, House Branchport Building 1994
Weaver, Solomon, House Branchport Building 1994
Whitaker House Benton Building 1994
Wilkinson, Jemima, House Jerusalem Building 1994
Williams, Sherman, House and Fruit Barn Jerusalem Building 1994
Willis, Christopher, House Dresden Building 1994
Wilson, Milton, House Rushville Building 1994
Woodworth, Abner, House Benton Building 1994
Wrightman, Dr. James, House Branchport Building 1994
Yates County Courthouse Park District Penn Yan District 1979
Yatesville Methodist Church Potter Building 1994
Young-Leach Cobblestone Farmhouse and Barn Complex Torrey Building 1992

State Historic Preservation Office

Nominations, tax-credit certifications and official records for New York go through the New York State Historic Preservation Office. See how to nominate a property.